Skip to content

The Assumption of Mary

2009 August 4
by Gordon Reid


I have stood at the spot from which Mary was assumed into heaven. At least I think I have.

When I was chaplain in the British Embassy in Ankara, the capital of Turkey, I had many visitors, and one of the places I most enjoyed taking them was Ephesus, just down the coast from Izmir, the ancient Smyrna. The Apostle John was the first Bishop of Ephesus, and it was there he took the Blessed Virgin when Jesus spoke ¬†from the Cross, and entrusted Mary into his care. “Son, behold thy Mother”.

The ruins of Ephesus are spectacular, and so well excavated that you can walk down whole streets which still have the grooves in them made by the Roman chariots. The library of Celsus must have been one of the most beautiful buildings of the ancient Greek world, and the great open-air theatre is almost complete and so well constructed that from the topmost tier you can hear the voice of someone talking quietly on the stage.

Above Ephesus is a steep hill at the top of which is a small chapel called “Mary’s House”. This is where Our Lady is supposed to have lived. It seems very out of the way and remote, but it may be that this was necessary if the early Christians in Ephesus were under suspicion and persecution. To capture the Mother of the false Messiah would have been a great triumph for the Jews or the Romans; so maybe she was hidden away on the hillside.

The structure of the House of the Virgin (Meryemana in Turkish) has been dated by archeologists to the 6th or 7th century, but its foundations are much older and may well date to the first century A.D. It was a place of pilgrimage for centuries by the local Orthodox Christians till they were driven out by the Turks. It is now run by the Roman Catholic Church, but is a sacred place for both Christians and Muslims, who also believe in the Virgin Birth and honour Mary as the mother of the Prophet Jesus.

The modern history of the Virgin’s House is extraordinary. It was “rediscovered” in 1812 by a German nun, Sister Anne Catherine Emmerich, who never travelled away from her home, where she was confined to bed as an invalid. One day she fell into a trance and received the stigmata and described a vision of the Virgin Mary and John travelling from Jerusalem to Ephesus. She described Mary’s house in detail, and this was recorded by a writer named Brentano.

The German nun went on to say that the Virgin Mary died at the age of 64 and was buried in a cave near her house. When her coffin was opened soon after, however, only an empty shroud was found in it. The house was then turned into a chapel.

Years after this nun’s visions, a French priest named Gouyet read Brentano’s account and travelled to Ephesus to look for the Virgin’s house. He found a house matching the nun’s description and in 1891 two Lazarist priests and two Catholic officials went to Ephesus and found a small chapel in ruins and a damaged statue of the Virgin. The chapel was restored in 1897 and is still in the care of the Lazarist Fathers who celebrate mass there daily.

The Feast of the Assumption is one of the great days of the year at Mary’s house. Each year, Roman Catholic, Orthodox and Muslim clergy conduct a service together at the shrine, one of the rare occasions that this happens anywhere.

Of course Ephesus is not the only place which claims to be the site of Mary’s death and Assumption. There is also a strong tradition that she died in Jerusalem surrounded by all the apostles. But there was no trace of this belief until the sixth century and it sounds too neat to me. I think it is much more likely that she stayed with John in Ephesus as commanded by her Son, and died there.

As far as her bodily assumption into heaven is concerned, to me the strongest argument for this as being believed from the earliest days is that there has never been a trace of a relic of the Blessed Virgin’s body, unlike the great quantity of the bones of the saints from the Apostles onwards. And theologically, the doctrine is both compelling and fitting for Catholic Christians. John himself in his Apocalypse saw ‘A great wonder in heaven: a woman clothed with the sun, with the moon at her feet, and round her head a crown of twelve stars” – the very same woman he had seen baking bread in that little hidden house at Ephesus years before – now Queen of Heaven.

3 Responses leave one →
  1. Stephen permalink
    August 5, 2009

    Thank you for such interesting details about the house from which Our Lady is believed to have been Assumed into Heaven. Thank God, my parish will have a High Mass befitting such a Solemn Feast! It makes me feel a strong kinship with my Anglo-Catholic brothers and sisters, when i recall what a resplendid offering the High Mass for the Assumption was at St Clement’s when i visited on an August 15th several years ago.

    Alas, i suspect most of my fellow Roman Catholics here in the United States won’t have the oppurtunity to attend Mass for the Assumption this year, because the feast happens to fall on a Saturday. The Assumption is one of those Holy Days for which Mass attendance becomes “optional” when it falls on a Saturday or a Monday, so most parishes don’t schedule any extra Masses beyond what they’d normally offer on an ordinary Saturday or Monday. I find this situation sad. It not only diminishes devotion to Our Lady, it also does a very good job of thoroughly confusing the faithful.

  2. August 16, 2009

    Thank you, Father Reid, for this interesting write-up about Ephesus and the Assumption of Our Lady. Thank you also for recommending this blog in your sermon at the beautiful Solemn High Mass of the Assumption held today at St. Clement’s.
    I hope you know, Father, how grateful the entire traditional community is for all that you and St. Clement’s does for us.
    Cujus festum colimus ipsa Virgo virginum intercedat pro nobis ad Dominum!
    Most cordially,
    Rudy Masciantonio

    Dr. Rudolph Masciantonio
    Chairman, Philadelphia Chapter, Latin Liturgy Association, Inc.
    429 S. 20th St., #A
    Philadelphia, PA 19146
    telephone: 215 732 6431

  3. October 20, 2009

    Great post Father. The Daughter of Charity recognized by the Church as the Foundress of Mary’s House is Sister Marie de Mandat-Grancey. As Vice President of the Sister Marie de Mandat-Grancey Foundation my mission is to spread the good news of Sister Marie making her known to many far and wide while working for her beatification. Consider reading more at and signing the online petition. Also available are printable prayer cards, printable information booklets and more. Thank you!

Leave a Reply

Note: You can use basic XHTML in your comments. Your email address will never be published.

Subscribe to this comment feed via RSS

Facebook Auto Publish Powered By :